quelle


 15 Jun 2010 @ 10:57 PM 
 

RC South

 

I’ve traveled to the south (Helmand Province) several times now. Much of my time has been spent with the Brits at Camp Bastion, Nad e Ali, and now Lashkar Gah. From a COIN standpoint, while there is work to do, the Brits are doing better. The current Brigadier has taken a quantum step forward with a directive to execute a standardize tool pack that includes an ASCOPE/PMESII crosswalk for each operational area.

This directive will pay tremendous dividends in each locality. It’s also a change. Using a standard toolset may sound like common sense, but it’s not a forgone conclusion by any means. Because of training, which has been mostly kinetic in focus, units have arrived on the ground in Afghanistan for years knowing lttle about counterinsurgency. The British are by no means alone in this at all, and they are actively addressing the issue.

Americans, for instance, have focused largely on kinetic tasks and we have scared the crap out of our Soldiers in training. Young Soldiers are convinced that danger lurks everywhere. Implicit is the idea that aggressiveness and estreme suspicion are what is required to survive. Also implied that only the unwary are killed. Many young Soldiers, NCOs and officers come over here determined to be too smart and aggressive to die here. We have failed to truly prepare our Soldiers, and especially the leaders, for what is required of them in a COIN environment.

Along with this has come an ignorance of the doctrine available. Of American field grade officers and senior NCOs who arrive at the CTC-A, the consistent answer in informal (“raise your hand if…”) polls is that 15% have read FM 3-24 Counterinsurgency. Still, the number of units on the ground who are willing to attempt COIN rather than counter-guerrilla type operations has markedly improved. The British currently on the ground are among these. This is part of my growing optimism.

It’s true that there are enough examples still, even among the British, that a “sharpshooter” could tear holes in my observations. I could point them out myself. What I’m talking about is a trend. The Marines have also had some successes, but I was depressed to hear a battalion-level Marine Warrant Officer explaining how his unit had arrived without any COIN training whatsoever… but that they had killed 8 or 9 bad guys since arriving a couple of weeks ago. I wanted to scream. My compatriots told me that I showed enormous gentleness in my questions. I don’t blame him. Really, it’s not about blame.

Obviously, there is still a lot of hit-and-miss COIN going on. It’s the training back in the national training bases that sets the tone. One Army unit, somewhat lionized by a previously acclaimed independent journalist who recently left after a lengthy embed, trained not on COIN, but from the old Counter-Guerrilla Operations manual. Their actions showed this as well. They managed to rack up the highest casualty rate of all Army units currently in theater and were subsequently removed from their operational area and given a different mission. The journalist, who would have had you believe that he was with a unit doing great things, unfortunately doesn’t know what good COIN looks like. He was offered a seat during the COIN Leader’s Course last August, but he begged off citing, “Time is money.” Had he come, he may have had the knowledge to better report on what he saw. Sadly, the untrained observer will do things like that. Education is a key.

The current training requirements are not driven by what GEN McChrystal wants to see executed on the ground. That, however, is about to undergo a massive change, driven by a memo by no less than the Secretary of Defense himself.

Watch for more on that.

The point here is not to indict anyone. The point is that we ARE learning. Granted, it could have come sooner, but this has been a learning process. The changes do not bear fruit immediately. Set your expectations for a tough summer, but expect progress. Indicators such as the British in the areas aroung Lashkar Gah and their forward-thinking Brigadier are keys to the developing trends. Much more work is going on behind the scenes, even in the States, that will change the trajectory of units that will deploy in the months ahead. McChrystal’s strategy, and the support being generated from the SECDEF on down, will begin to alter the outcomes as units employ these techniques because they were trained in them prior to arrival in-country.

Tags Categories: Afghanistan, COIN Posted By: Old Blue
Last Edit: 15 Jun 2010 @ 10 57 PM

EmailPermalink
 

Responses to this post » (5 Total)

 
  1. elf says:

    When you won’t rid yourself of giant ossified bureaucracies like TRADOC and FORSCOM, you’ll damn yourself to not being able to adapt. FORSCOM training for NG soldiers at CP Shelby in 05 actively worked against what we should be doing on many levels.

    Or any level.

    I’m glad to hear you see it getting better. I am not certain we have the time there to make it work. Meanwhile what’s going on at Marja?

  2. LTCZ says:

    Not that it matters much, but your Brit Brigadier’s approach, the ASCOPE/PMESII matrix, is based on futures research methods. The model is called Cross-Impact Analysis or Event-Impact Matrix Analysis. It is used to figure out what programs one needs to get from an unfortunate present to a desired future. It does fit the nature of the task in your world, doesnt it?

    One thing, though. PMESII is a terrifically flawed way to define the operating environment especially for civic aciton. PMESII is designed to be a targeting method for the environment (John Waldron of USAF fame invented the method.) That’s why PMESII is associated with EBO (another bozo idea.) A better subsitute for PMESII in your part of the world would be to lay out the environment according to Social, Technological, Economic, Political, Environmental and Military (STEP-EM) factors. This latter approach is used in many non-US military cross-impact efforts similar to what the Brits are doing.

    Hope this isn’t TMI (too much information.) Stay safe as the mission allows!

  3. dave says:

    This is the second time you have mentioned the low rate of familiarzation with the COIN manual. One would think that it would be required for all officers and NCO’s to have studied the material and passed some exams on it before the unit deploys. If the leaders of a unit have failed to do so before deploying it should become a black mark on thier record.

    The unit you mentioned that was reassigned all the officers should be looking for new employment in short order. Until you start firing people nothing will change.

  4. [...] of the comments on the last post, “RC South,” brought me to realize that the ASCOPE/PMESII crosswalk needs some explanation. Here is the [...]

  5. elf says:

    Blue,

    Post more on AM – that cheered me up…

    And the Pope needs (or someone of the Pro school) to get some home based IO going…

Post a Comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

\/ More Options ...
Change Theme...
  • Users » 1
  • Posts/Pages » 306
  • Comments » 1,707
  • It considers the metabolism, photosynthesis, lipids, and membranes. It also reviews the relevant bioenergetic principles of photosynthesis, bioluminescence, photoinactivation and mutation. This course deals with the metabolic and physiologic concepts related to proteins and carbohydrates, their function and structure. DRUNK DRIVER KILLS SIX ON CALFORNIA FREEWAY Authorities have identified a suspected drunk driver who they say drove the wrong direction on the 60 Freeway in Diamond Bar early Sunday canadian pharmacy accutane and caused an accident that killed six people. Olivia Carolee Culbreath, 21, of Fontana has been arrested on suspicion of felony DUI and felony manslaughter, said Rodrigo Jimenez, a California Highway Patrol spokesman on the scene. USC Medical Center with a broken femur and a ruptured bladder, Jimenez said. Culbreath was heading east on the westbound 60 Freeway about 4:40 a. At least two people were ejected from their vehicles, he said. The extent and determinants of prescribing and adherence with acid-reducing medications: a national claims database study. Barrison AF, Jarboe LA, Weinberg BM et al. Patterns of proton pump inhibitor use in clinical practice. Van der Stok J, Van Lieshout EM, El-Massoudi Y, Van Kralingen GH, Patka P. Bone substitutes in the Netherlands - a systematic literature review. Donovan O, Galvin R, Quinlan JF, O'Dwyer J. Influence of Antibiotic Addition and Retained Moisture on the Mechanical Properties of Synthetic Bone Graft Materials. British Trauma Society Annual Scientific Meeting. Queens Hotel, Leeds, UK.. My name is Crister Brady. I am passionate about adventures by bicycle. In fact, my travels and experiences on a bike have led me towards a career working with underserved communities in medicine. Educational Safaris, and now plan and lead them. Building http://jerseycanada.com/jerseyatlantic/fnt/ultramer.php from these experiences, I have been able to take advantage of opportunities on and off a bike. Persönlichkeit des am 13. Oktober 1821 in Schivelbein (Hinterpommern) geborenen Rudolf Virchow ausmachten. Kampfgetümmel lag ihm jedoch weit mehr. Von Juli 1848 bis Juni 1849 gab er zusammen mit Rudolf Leubuscher ein weiteres Journal heraus. Diesmal jedoch ging es um eine sozialpolitische Wochenschrift mit dem Titel Die medicinische Reform. Komplementärseite des Naturwissenschaftlers Rudolf Virchow. Correlation between degree of conversion, filler concentration and mechanical properties of posterior composite resins. Journal of Oral Rehabilitation. Mallmann A, Jacques LB, Valandro LF, Mathias P and Muench A. Microtensile bond strength of light- and self-cured adhesive systems to intraradicular dentin using a translucent fiber post. Aksornmuang J, Foxton RM, Nakajima M and Tagami J. Microtensile bond strength of a dual-cure resin core material to glass and quartz fibre posts. Hope may be the only crutch a patient has to keep their optimism. Nurses care enough to honor that hope and support the patient. We view that patient as whole and complete. Hope is guided by our commitment as nurses to our patients. It is also clouded with preconceived beliefs and morals that we are reared with.. caressing viagra apotheke kaufen ohne rezept kosten viagra apotheke Burlington forefathers viagra ohne rezept erfahrungen viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland Acapulco ventures preisvergleich viagra rezeptfrei billig cialis 20mg nonnegative acheter cialis Sheraton vente viagra en france
    buspar online
Change Theme...
  • VoidVoid « Default
  • LifeLife
  • EarthEarth
  • WindWind
  • WaterWater
  • FireFire
  • LightLight

About Blue



    No Child Pages.
custom essay writing service buyanessaysonline.com